Filter by

Filter by

• Filter and sort
• Filter and sort
• Product
  # selected Clear Selected

  • All Cheeses (40)
  • Cheese Boxes (5)
  • Curds (5)
  • Flavored Cheeses (5)
  • Meats (1)
  • Smoked Cheeses (7)
• Kind
  # selected Clear Selected

  • Cheddars (18)
  • Farmers (1)
  • Gouda (2)
  • Havarti (2)
  • Jacks (6)
  • Mozzarella (1)
  • Muenster (1)
  • Parmesan (1)
  • Provolone (2)
  • Swiss (2)
• Flavor
  # selected Clear Selected
• Type
  # selected Clear Selected
• Clear all

2 Year Aged White Cheddar

$6.55 – $45.50

2 Year aged Dutch White Cheddar

Select

3 Year Aged Cheddar

$6.95 – $48.50

3 Year Aged Dutch Cheddar Cheese

Select

3 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar

$6.95 – $48.50

3 Year Aged Yellow Dutch Cheddar

Select

Aged Yellow Cheddar

$6.30 – $44.00

Aged Yellow Cheddar, meticulously aged for 12 months

Select

Colby Jack

$5.80 – $38.50

Colby Jack is a delightful cheese that combines the rich, creamy flavors of Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses.
Known

Select

Colored Muenster

$39.99

Dutch Muenster with the Annatto natural coloring on the outside. Available in 6 lb blocks only

Select

Cooper Sharp Black Pepper

$39.99

The Original Sharp Black Pepper Cooper American. Creamy and Indulgent, with a kick of black pepper. Available in 5 lb loafs

Select

Cooper Sharp White

$39.99

The Original Cooper Sharp White American Cheese Creamy and Indulgent, available in 5 lb loafs

Select

Dutch Swiss

$8.70 – $43.50

Local Swiss with a rich, creamy, and slightly nutty flavor.

Select

Dutchman’s Special Premium Aged Cheddar

$8.99 – $54.99

Our finest and truest aged cheddar to date! The Dutchman's Special is

Select

Extra Sharp Cheddar

$6.95 – $48.50

Aged to perfection, and blended with a hint of parmesan to give it a bold but sweet flavor.

Select

Farmers Cheese

$34.99

Our farmers cheese is a semi-soft cheese with a creamy texture and a mild, buttery flavor. - Try it today, you won't

Select

Garlic & Herb Cheese Curds

$6.49

Garden Lovers Special Seasoning on our all Time Favorite Dutch Curd. Our curds are small pieces of fresh cheddar before aging.

Select

Garlic & Herb Jack

$6.50 – $44.25

Creamy Jack cheese infused with a delicious blend of garlic and herbs

Select

Garlic Jalopeno’ Cheese Curd

$6.49

Dutchman's Special Garlic Jalopeno Cheese Curds Don't let the name trick you. You cannot tell that it has Jalopeno it has

Select

Gouda

$6.30 – $44.00

Dutch Gouda cheese is a sweet, creamy, yellow Cheese made in the traditional Dutch manner.

Select

Gourmet Cheese Box – 12 PC

$69.99

Now you can try multiple flavors at once with our Sampler Special!

Packed with 12 blocks of our Dutch Country cheese,

Select

Gourmet Cheese Box – 4 PC

$27.99

Now you can try multiple flavors at once with our Sampler Special!

Packed with 4

Select

Gourmet Cheese Box – 6 PC

$34.99

Packed with 6 blocks of our Dutch Country cheese, this box will make the perfect gift for any cheese-loving fanatic.

Select

Havarti

$8.70 – $61.80

Dutch Havarti This semi-soft cheese is creamy, smooth, and supple in texture. Be amazed by how buttery and rich it is—perfectly

Select

Havarti Dill

$10.45 – $62.70

Buttery and rich havarti with a tinge of garden dill

Select

Horseradish Cheddar

$6.50 – $44.25

Creamy Cheddar with a kick of Horseradish

Select

Mild White Cheddar

$5.80 – $38.50

Mild White Dutch Cheddar with creamy texture, and flavor

Select

Mild Yellow Cheddar

$7.70 – $38.50

Dutch Mild Yellow Cheddar

Select

Monterey Jack

$5.80 – $38.50

Award Winning Dutch Monterey Jack cheese. It has a mild, buttery flavor and a pale-yellow color with a compact and

Select

Natural Cheese Curds

$6.49

Dutchman's All Natural Cheese Curds Our curds are small pieces of fresh cheddar before aging. They have a squeaky, fresh and

Select

Old Bay Cheese Curds

$6.49

Old Bay Deluxe Dutch Curds Our curds are small pieces of fresh cheddar before aging. They have a squeaky, fresh and

Select

Onion n Chives Cheddar

$6.25 – $43.75

Spring Onion flavored Cheddar

Select

Parmesan

$6.50 – $45.50

Nutty, Bold, Complex. Perfect for grating, or shaving over salads and chicken dishes.

Select

Pepper Jack

$6.50 – $45.50

Add some Zest to your meal with Our Pepper Jack Cheese. Made with a Jack base with a medium amount of

Select

Premium “Aged Cheddar” Box

$42.99

This box features a variety of our Premium Reserve aged cheddars, as well as a pack of our Dutch Country

Select

Provolone

$39.99 Original price was: $39.99.$34.99Current price is: $34.99.

Dutch Provolone - Fresh and mild in flavor, Try adding to your favorite sandwich for an extra burst of flavor.. Available in 6

Select

Queso Menonita

$6.49 – $44.25

Soft, buttery cheese great for melting or snacking. *

Select

Schreiber’s White American – 120 Sliced

$29.99

  Pre-sliced White American cheese, 120 slices per 5 lb block

Select

Shreiber’s Yellow American – 120 sliced

$29.99

Pre-sliced Yellow American cheese, 120 slices per 5 lb block

Select

Smoked Gouda

$7.45 – $50.75

Smoked in house. Rich, creamy gouda smoked to perfection

Select

Smoked Mild Yellow Cheddar

$8.85 – $44.25

Mild Yellow Dutch Cheddar with a tinge of Natural Wood Smoke

Select

Smoked Monterey Jack

$6.80 – $44.25

Award Winning Dutch Monterey Jack cheese With a bold touch of Natural Wood Smoke. It has a mild, buttery flavor

Select

Smoked Provolone

$8.70 – $44.75

Wood Smoked Provolone, smoked in house

Select

Smoked Sharp Cheddar

$7.95 – $51.75

Premium Extra Sharp Cheddar with a bold tinge of Natural Wood Smoke

Select

Smoked Sharp White Cooper

$8.95 – $44.99

Sharp white Cooper cheese, smoked to perfection

Select

Smoked Swiss

$9.70 – $56.50

Hardy Natural Wood Smoked Dutch Swiss Is firm, and slightly nutty with an amazing smoke flavor.

Select

Spicy Cajun Cheese Curds

$6.49

  An Amazing Mild Spicy Cajun Cheese Curds Not an overpowering Cajun just a mild kick. Let them warm up to room

Select

Sweet Bologna w/ Cheese Snack Sticks

$8.49

The perfect blend of sweet bologna and cheese, now served in a snack-sized meat stick. - These are a must try, and

Select

The “Jack” Box

$39.99

Featuring 6 assorted blocks of our Dutch Country jack cheeses

Your package will ship in an insulated box and

Select

WM Mozzarella

$39.99

Fresh Whole Milk Mozzarella. Available in 6lb rolls

Select